Source Job

US 4w PTO

  • Supervise and develop a team of multi-line claim professionals handling complex casualty claims.
  • Provide technical guidance on coverage analysis, contractual risk transfer, and litigation strategy for high-exposure claims.
  • Partner with clients and defense counsel to drive timely, accurate claim resolutions and maintain strong relationships.

Claims Management Coverage Analysis Litigation Management Team Leadership

20 jobs similar to Multi-Line Claim Supervisor – Captive Programs (Construction & Agribusiness)

Jobs ranked by similarity.

$70,000–$90,000/yr
US 3w PTO

  • Investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and resolve moderate to highly complex casualty claims, including construction defect, general liability, commercial transportation, and auto bodily injury claims.
  • Independently evaluate coverage, liability, damages, and exposure while ensuring compliance with policy provisions and legal requirements.
  • Manage litigated files, partner with defense counsel, and mentor team members while delivering exceptional customer service.

West Bend is a mutual property and casualty insurance company serving individuals and businesses. Recognized as a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Top Workplace for 14 consecutive years, including being named number one on three occasions, the company fosters a welcoming culture where associates are valued and supported.

US 4w PTO

  • Handle a book of Commercial Casualty Excess/Umbrella claims throughout the entire claims life cycle.
  • Conduct investigations, determine coverage, set reserves, negotiate settlements, and settle claims within authority limits.
  • Manage outside counsel, mentor staff, and stay current on legislation affecting specialty coverage.

Liberty Mutual is a global insurance company providing a wide range of products and services. With a focus on inclusion and well-being, it supports employees through comprehensive benefits and development opportunities.

$130,000–$160,000/yr
US Unlimited PTO

  • Own claims end to end for commercial accounts, from intake to resolution.
  • Lead kickoff calls, monthly claim reviews, and be the client's first call when incidents occur.
  • Build SOPs and reporting workflows while pushing carriers and TPAs for movement.

WithCoverage replaces traditional insurance brokerage with AI-supercharged risk management for modern economy clients like GoPuff and Bombas. The company has raised over $43M from Sequoia, 8VC, and Khosla Ventures and offers a collaborative, transparent culture.

$46,000–$84,000/yr
US 3w PTO

  • Investigates and processes commercial claims, evaluating coverage and damages within assigned authority.
  • Communicates directly with insureds, claimants, agents, and internal customers to resolve claims.
  • Documents claim files, negotiates settlements, and identifies fraud or subrogation potential.

Liberty Mutual is a global insurance company offering commercial and personal insurance products and services. With a fast-growing and inclusive culture, the company values employee development, well-being, and diversity across its large national workforce.

$75,000–$85,000/yr
US 4w PTO

  • Investigate, evaluate, and adjust multi-line liability claims, ensuring compliance with client requirements and jurisdictional regulations.
  • Manage a portfolio of auto, municipal, and general liability claims from assignment through resolution.
  • Coordinate litigation, negotiate settlements, and communicate effectively with clients and stakeholders.

CCMSI, the largest privately-owned Third Party Administrator (TPA), partners with global clients to solve complex risk management challenges. A certified Great Place to Work®, our employee-owners are empowered to grow, collaborate, and make meaningful contributions every day.

US 4w PTO

  • Manage complex commercial energy claims, including coverage analysis, litigation, and settlement negotiation.
  • Serve as a subject matter expert on energy-specific issues and mentor less experienced claims professionals.
  • Collaborate with underwriting, reinsurance, and legal teams to influence claims strategy and outcomes.

Liberty Mutual is a Fortune 100 insurance company providing a wide range of insurance products and services. They have a large, inclusive workforce with a focus on employee well-being and professional development.

US 4w PTO

  • Manage the investigation, evaluation, and resolution of complex auto and homeowner's casualty claims, including severe and catastrophic injuries.
  • Collaborate closely with trial counsel and attend mediations, arbitrations, trials, hearings, and conferences.
  • Maintain accurate reserves, oversee counsel billing, and identify suspicious claims for SIU or subrogation.

Liberty Mutual is a global insurance company that provides property and casualty insurance, showing up for people in their toughest moments. With a large and diverse workforce, the company fosters an inclusive culture that values professionalism, integrity, and empathy, and invests in employees' growth and well-being.

US 4w PTO

  • Own complex environmental casualty claims from first notice through resolution with authority to decide coverage, set reserves, and settle.
  • Drive litigation strategy by reviewing pleadings, directing defense counsel, and negotiating settlements.
  • Mentor colleagues and serve as a liaison to Underwriting, Reinsurance, and other business partners.

Liberty Mutual is a Fortune 100 insurance company providing commercial and personal insurance products, known for financial strength and customer advocacy. The company fosters an inclusive culture that values diverse perspectives and supports professional growth.

$92,000–$120,000/yr
US

  • Manages claim strategies and resolutions while advocating for optimal client outcomes.
  • Communicates claim information to internal and external clients and maintains strong relationships.
  • Develops expertise in multiple coverage lines and participates in presentations and new business pitches.

IMA Financial Group is an independent insurance brokerage providing risk management, employee benefits, and wealth management solutions. With a focus on associate ownership and team-based culture, the company has been recognized as a best place to work by multiple publications and operates nationally.

US

  • Adjust the most complex and high exposure Allied Health claims requiring advanced technical expertise and negotiation.
  • Investigate coverage, draft reservation of rights, and manage litigation with defense counsel and experts.
  • Collaborate with internal and external stakeholders to drive optimal resolution strategies.

Integrated Specialty Coverages is a technology and data-driven commercial MGA and insurance wholesaler. Backed by Onex Partners, it combines insurance and technology to drive innovation and growth.

$75,000–$85,000/yr
US 4w PTO

  • Investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and resolve liability claims across multiple commercial accounts and jurisdictions.
  • Manage a diverse portfolio of low, moderate, and high-complexity liability claims from first notice through resolution.
  • Coordinate with claimants, insureds, clients, attorneys, and vendors while maintaining accurate documentation and compliance.

CCMSI is a Third Party Administrator that provides customized claim solutions and risk management services for global clients. As the largest privately-owned TPA, CCMSI is a certified Great Place to Work with an employee-ownership culture focused on collaboration and meaningful contributions.

$60,000–$70,000/yr
US

  • Analyze complex liability claims to determine benefits and ensure timely resolution.
  • Negotiate settlements within authority and identify subrogation opportunities.
  • Communicate claim activity with claimants, clients, and excess carriers.

Sedgwick is a global risk and claims administration partner helping clients navigate the unexpected. With over 33,000 colleagues worldwide, we foster a caring, inclusive culture.

US

  • Managing a team of Auto/Liability Adjusters, coordinating training and development.
  • Ensuring compliance with statutes, regulations, and company procedures.
  • Investigating claims, estimating damages, determining liability, and handling litigation.

Cottingham & Butler Claims Services is an insurance company that helps clients through life's toughest moments. The company hires and develops driven people and promotes a culture guided by 'Better Every Day'.

$70,000–$80,000/yr
US 4w PTO

  • Independently manage a caseload of General Liability claims from assignment through closure.
  • Investigate coverage, liability, causation, and damages to determine claim exposure and resolution strategy.
  • Negotiate settlements within authority and manage litigated files with defense counsel.

CCMSI is the largest privately-owned Third Party Administrator, delivering customized claim management solutions for complex risk challenges. The company is employee-owned, empowering team members to take ownership and drive results in a collaborative environment.

$40,666–$63,630/yr
Canada

  • Investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and resolve complex property claims, including litigated and environmental losses.
  • Conduct coverage analysis and collaborate with legal, engineering, and restoration experts on complex files.
  • Provide technical guidance, mentoring, and strong customer service in a fully remote environment.

The hiring company is an insurance organization specializing in complex property claims management and customer support. It operates as a fully remote Canadian team and emphasizes flexibility, professional development, and community involvement.

$90,000–$115,000/yr
US

  • Adjudicate high-end General Liability claims involving serious injuries, complex coverage scenarios, and legal disputes.
  • Develop case strategies for satisfactory resolution, coordinating with local counsel, clients, and medical or legal experts.
  • Work in a remote, flexible environment with opportunities for career growth and comprehensive benefits.

Sedgwick is the world's leading risk and claims administration partner, helping clients navigate the unexpected with expertise and AI-enabled technology. With over 33,000 colleagues and 10,000 clients across 80 countries, Sedgwick provides a caring culture, professional development, and work-life balance.

US 4w PTO

  • Independently manage moderate to complex general liability claims from investigation through final resolution.
  • Evaluate coverage, liability, damages, and exposure while managing litigated claims with defense counsel.
  • Deliver responsive client service, maintain accurate documentation, and ensure compliance with claim-handling standards.

Our partner is a third-party claims administrator delivering high-quality general liability claims management. They foster a supportive, collaborative, team-oriented culture built on integrity, accountability, service quality, and shared success.

US

  • Manage an inventory of workers' compensation claims to evaluate compensability and liability.
  • Plan and conduct investigations to confirm coverage, determine damages, and negotiate settlements within authority limits.
  • Maintain detailed claim files, authorize timely payments, and represent the company at arbitrations, mediations, or trials.

National Interstate, a member of Great American Insurance Group, provides commercial transportation insurance and alternative risk transfer programs across all 50 states. Its dedicated team has earned multiple Top Workplace honors, with a culture built on integrity, transparency, collaboration, and employee development.

$94,458–$179,048/yr
US

  • Investigate and resolve high-severity property claims with empathy and decisive action.
  • Conduct on-site inspections, create detailed estimates using Xactimate, and manage claim files.
  • Negotiate fair settlements and collaborate with internal and external stakeholders.

Mercury Insurance helps people reduce risk and overcome unexpected events. With over 60 years of experience, it is a midsize company that fosters growth, inclusion, and teamwork.

US 3w PTO

  • Acquire investigative techniques and work with experts to determine accident causes and fault.
  • Independently manage a claims inventory, including investigations, medical record reviews, and damage evaluations.
  • Resolve cases by negotiating settlements with individuals or attorneys.

Liberty Mutual is a leading property and casualty insurer helping people embrace today and confidently pursue tomorrow. They are a Fortune 100 company recognized as a Great Place to Work and one of Forbes' best employers for diversity and new graduates.